In the area of social studies subjects, questions that require knowledge to be solved, so called “Memorization quiz” are often found. For example, the typical question is as follows.
In order to find the correct answer to a question like this, it is necessary to judge whether each choice is a historical fact or not. Since the historical facts are written in textbooks or reference books, if we memorize the contents of the textbooks or the reference books, we would be able to choose correct options.
It may appear that computers are adept at solving this kind of question because they can memorize data infinitely. Computers are excellent at root-learning of the data (memorization in an exact, word for word manner) in fact, but it does not necessarily mean that computers acquire this concept. Therefore, the system capable to judge on its concept (i.e. knowledge) is required rather than the root-learning of the contents of the textbooks or the reference books. It can be said that understanding the concept written in natural language and using it as knowledge, means recognizing the meaning of natural language. This is an important theme in the research of natural language processing, and an unsolved difficult challenge, which is the key technology in various applications relevant to natural language.
In natural language processing, where two sentences t1 and t2 are given, the technology to recognize whether it can be said that “if t1 is assumed true, t2 is considered to be true too”, is called textual entailment recognition.
Question like the one above can be solved when textual entailment recognition is applied. For example, a textbook has the explanation like the following about answer choice 1 of the previous question.
According to this description, (1) should be chosen as the correct answer.
This amounts to processing by textual entitlement recognition as follows.
It is natural judgment for a human. However, this judgment cannot be made by a computer. Now we are advancing research on the techniques for performing textual entailment recognition with high precision.
Moreover, we are holding the RITE (Recognizing Inference in TExt ) task-oriented workshop on the theme of textual entailment recognition, in the NTCIR (Nii Test Collection for IR systems), a series of evaluation workshops. RITE also offers the evaluation data created from the questions of the National Center Test for University Admissions, and has been pursuing research that solves questions requiring knowledge through research of textual entailment recognition.
Choose the most appropriate sentence that describes military systems and soldiers.
(1) The Janissaries were the standing army of the Ottoman Empire.
(2) After the Punic Wars, the farming class, who had served as hoplites, were economically affluent.
(2009 Academic Year Main Examination: World History B)
In order to find the correct answer to a question like this, it is necessary to judge whether each choice is a historical fact or not. Since the historical facts are written in textbooks or reference books, if we memorize the contents of the textbooks or the reference books, we would be able to choose correct options.
It may appear that computers are adept at solving this kind of question because they can memorize data infinitely. Computers are excellent at root-learning of the data (memorization in an exact, word for word manner) in fact, but it does not necessarily mean that computers acquire this concept. Therefore, the system capable to judge on its concept (i.e. knowledge) is required rather than the root-learning of the contents of the textbooks or the reference books. It can be said that understanding the concept written in natural language and using it as knowledge, means recognizing the meaning of natural language. This is an important theme in the research of natural language processing, and an unsolved difficult challenge, which is the key technology in various applications relevant to natural language.
In natural language processing, where two sentences t1 and t2 are given, the technology to recognize whether it can be said that “if t1 is assumed true, t2 is considered to be true too”, is called textual entailment recognition.
Question like the one above can be solved when textual entailment recognition is applied. For example, a textbook has the explanation like the following about answer choice 1 of the previous question.
Ottoman Empire - A great power of Mediterranean
…The Janissaries were the standing army under the emperor, which were consisting of military bands, a corps of engineers, artillery units, musketeers, etc., and it was a precursor of the modern military which had developed in Europe later.
(2007 Academic Year Textbook: World History B, Tokyo Shoseki publishing)
According to this description, (1) should be chosen as the correct answer.
This amounts to processing by textual entitlement recognition as follows.
t1: The Janissaries were the standing army under the emperor, which were consisting of military bands, a corps of engineers, artillery units, musketeers, etc., and it was a precursor of the modern military which had developed in Europe later.
t2: The Janissaries were the standing army of the Ottoman Empire.
It is natural judgment for a human. However, this judgment cannot be made by a computer. Now we are advancing research on the techniques for performing textual entailment recognition with high precision.
Moreover, we are holding the RITE (Recognizing Inference in TExt ) task-oriented workshop on the theme of textual entailment recognition, in the NTCIR (Nii Test Collection for IR systems), a series of evaluation workshops. RITE also offers the evaluation data created from the questions of the National Center Test for University Admissions, and has been pursuing research that solves questions requiring knowledge through research of textual entailment recognition.